Ship Captain Emotionally Distressed When Vessel Crashed Into Forties Echo Platform

Source: EnergyVoice

A ship captain was emotionally distressed when the vessel he was in charge of collided with a North Sea oil rig, a tribunal heard today.

The Forties Echo platform was evacuated after the accident with the Sea Falcon offshore tug on March 16 last year.

Apache, which operates numerous installations off the coast of Scotland, was handed an improvement notice by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) following the incident.

The notice ordered the firm to make significant changes to the way it monitors marine traffic within a 500 metre radius “safety zone” of the rig.

But the oil and gas firm is now appealing the notice insisting that staff took the appropriate action to reduce risk to its employees and the vessel crew.

At a tribunal held in Aberdeen today, Apache’s legal representative, solicitor Peter Gray, argued that it was the responsibility of the ship crew to make sure it was operated safely.

And he said the master of the vessel was under “emotional distress” at the time of the accident because he had received bad news of a family member by email before he took control of the vessel.

Mr Gray asked Alan Pemberton, a specialist inspector from the HSE who was involved in the investigation, whether he was aware of factors leading up to the collision.

Mr Pemberton replied: “I was aware of an issue with the master being distressed, perhaps because of the bad news he had received.

“Clearly that was perhaps something the installation was not made aware of.

“One question was whether he should have continued what he was doing, I don’t know.”

Mr Pemberton suggested that oil rig staff should have been monitoring the ship to make sure it was being operated according to safe zone guidance.

He said: “Certainly in the early stages, if they had been monitoring right at the onset, and saw what was going on, then maybe if they had been doing that they could have contacted the vessel and challenged what the vessel was doing which may have refocused the master’s mind.”

The tribunal continues this afternoon.